Eureka! The Great Inflation was the result of demographic trends

This is what Steve Randy Waldman (SRW) wants us to believe, being highly praised by Steve Roth at Angry Bear who says that´s the point he didn´t ‘grab’ during 10 years researching the Great Inflation. From Steve Roth:

I’ve been worrying at the various Great-Inflation explanations for a decade, and I’ve never found them satisfying. Some seeming errors and contortions of economic logic aside, the imputed causes (OPEC?) have just never seemed big enough to bring about the massive economic effects we encountered.

This definitely does. Steve has added a (maybe the) crucial piece that allows me to understand

Scott Sumner has weighed in (here and here). In the comments section of Scotts first comment on SRW Mark Sadowski shows that a bunch of country experiences do not corroborate SRW´s ‘hypothesis’.

Maybe Germany at the time of unification is the most glaring example. In 1991 alone the labor force increased 24% through the absorption of the much less productive East German workers. The rise in NGDP in 1991 was 8.4%, above the average of 5.4% of the previous 10 years. During the following 10 years NGDP growth averaged only 3.2%.Inflation in the following 10 years averaged 2.4%, a bit below the average of 2.6% over the previous 10 years.

I bet Robert Hetzel, who 15 years ago wrote the ‘delicious’ “Arthur Burns and Inflation” does not agree at all with SRW´s ending:

Oh, and give poor Arthur Burns a break. You couldn’t have done any better.

A little over one year ago I posted “The Origins of the Great Inflation”. I didn´t see any place for demographics.

4 thoughts on “Eureka! The Great Inflation was the result of demographic trends

  1. Pingback: interfluidity » Agreeing in different languages

  2. It just gets whackier and whackier—and I am in the camp of being a little forgiving to the Fed of the 1960s and 1970s, and we did have solid real growth (something you cannot say about today).

    Maybe we can just go straight to astrology from here….

  3. Pingback: interfluidity » Terminal demographics

  4. Pingback: More on Population Growth as a Cause of Inflation: Mark Sadowski and Steve Waldman | Last Men and OverMen

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.